| Platinum | Little Big Burger |
| Gold | Cornucopia Restaurant |
| Silver | Killer Burger |
| Bronze | Viking Brewing Southtowne Pub |
| Top Pick | Marché |
| Top Pick | Northwest Burgers |
| Top Pick | Plank Town Brewing Company |
| Top Pick | Rennie's Landing |
| Top Pick | The Sandwich League |
| Top Pick | Way Back Burgers |
